Home »

Industry News and Articles

Fannie Mae Releases 1st PNA Guidance in Over 20 Years


Posted by Dianne Crocker

March 21, 2014

Consistency. Better Quality. Ease of Review

New year, new guidelines for property condition assessments. The latest change comes from Fannie Mae. Last year, it was Freddie Mac, and now, U.S. HUD is in the process of doing the same. This brief focuses on the impact of the new requirements from Fannie Mae for Physical Needs Assessments (or PNAs).

As a result of the lack of consistency of PNA reports for multifamily properties secured by loans purchased by Fannie Mae Multifamily, in February 2014, Fannie Mae Multifamily issued its first comprehensive PNA guidance in over 20 years. Among other things, the update includes new forms that serve as reference documents and templates that reflect an effort by Fannie Mae to establish minimum property evaluator qualifications, standardize report format and improve assessment quality and consistency. The purpose of this brief is to gauge how the industry is reacting to the new requirements since the release.  

Maintaining High Loan Standards 

To get a behind-the-scenes look at what prompted the new guidelines, EDR Insight reached out to Tammy Romero, Fannie Mae’s Credit Risk Analyst III, MF Risk Management. “Fannie Mae’s Multifamily Mortgage Business routinely reviews loan delivery requirements and guidance to maintain high loan standards and provide quality affordable housing,” said Romero. “Improved guidance on property conditions and improved minimum requirements provide a more thorough understanding of the physical condition of the properties financed by multifamily mortgage loans purchased by Fannie Mae. “The U.S. multifamily housing stock is aging. The Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies estimates that the average age of the nation’s multifamily housing stock is 38 years,” she continued. “Given the aging U.S. multifamily housing stock, Fannie Mae believes that improved understanding of property conditions is consistent with our mission to provide safe and affordable housing.”

A look at last year’s numbers sheds some light on why Fannie Mae has such an interest in stricter standards. Fannie Mae’s investment in multifamily housing is significant: In 2013 alone, Fannie Mae provided $28.8 billion in multifamily finance involving approximately 507,000 multifamily units (see accompanying table for a list of the top 10 DUS lenders in 2013).



What Changed? 

According to Fannie Mae, the improved guidance provides a more comprehensive approach to property conditions by:  

•    Providing explicit qualifications for the Property Evaluator as well as the representative from the Property Evaluator performing the on-site inspection;
•    Providing clearly defined property components and systems that must be addressed as part of the Physical Needs Assessment to improve the quality of information delivered as well as the identification of potential risks that may impact property operations or resident health and safety; 
•    Standardizing report format and tables to better identify errors and/or omissions while streamlining review; 
•    Identifying known problematic materials and providing clear guidance on evaluation; and
•    Improving management of property condition issues that must be addressed throughout the loan term.

Reaching a Higher Bar   

Key among the changes made by Fannie Mae to its PNA requirements are more stringent professional qualifications for property evaluators, which could narrow the field of providers who meet the higher bar (see text box). Among other things, the PNA report delivered to the lender “must be reviewed and certified by a professional engineer or by a licensed or registered architect, in good standing, or by an individual with appropriate experience and certifications in the construction field. The PNA Report should be signed by an employee of the property evaluation with experience (i) commensurate with the subject property type and scope (i.e., size, complexity, etc.) and (ii) in the property of PNA reports, and who is not a subcontractor of the property evaluator.”

Gregory Bailey, Director, Architectural & Engineering Technical Operations at EMG, believes that some firms may find it challenging to meet these new requirements. “The new property evaluator and reviewer qualifications, as well as the new special hazards requirements, pose the most difficulty because they require very high levels of education, industry experience and continuing education that many firms in the industry currently do not have,” Bailey says.


“This creates a steep learning curve for many providers of Property Condition Assessments. Going forward, firms doing work on Fannie Mae projects will need to ensure that their staff meets the education and experience requirements, find and hire new staff that does, or a combination of the two. We will likely see the pool of qualified professionals decrease as they are being sought after by various firms.” 

~Gregory Bailey, Director, Architectural & Engineering Technical Operations, EMG

As Bailey noted, EMG participated in the early piloting of the new standards, and as a result, "we actively prepared in advance of the effective date." Other firms that already prioritized internal training programs and certifications are expected to have an easier time of transitioning over. Additionally, Bailey notes, “These changes will help those companies that focused on quality in the past by raising the bar across the board.”

On the topic of whether the new requirements would impact the turnaround time of PNA reports, Partner Engineering and Science’s Aaron Kovan, Technical Director of Agency Services, had this to say in an FAQ published by Globe St.com“There is some concern in the industry that the changes could potentially lengthen the delivery date due to the more restrictive qualification requirements and ensuing difficulty to staff a project. The larger consulting firms will have a greater capacity to deal with these changes with minimal to no increase in schedule as they are better positioned to train employees and have a larger, generally more qualified staff.” 

Emphasis on Energy Reporting, Benchmarking

Benchmarking, the process of tracking a building's energy and water use and comparing it against past performance and against its peers, is now an important component of the Fannie Mae PNA requirements. The Fannie Mae Multifamily Selling and Service Guide guidance and new Form 4099 (i.e., the instructions for the Property Evaluator) have been updated to require properties located in jurisdictions that require reporting of energy consumption (currently required in Boston, Chicago, Washington DC, New York City and Seattle) to report Energy Use Intensity (EUI) for the EPA ENERGY STAR score (to be released this fall) to Fannie Mae as a way to gauge property performance and operation. The ENERGY STAR® score serves as a proxy for performance risk similar to the debt service coverage ratio, or DSCR (i.e., Does a property with a lower EUI or a higher ENERGY STAR® score have a healthier cash flow and lower risk in a volatile energy market?). Tracking energy consumption over time will allow for an analysis of whether there is a correlation between a property's ENERGY STAR® score and property cash flow. [For more on the new ENERGY STAR® score, see the note at the end of this brief.]

Feedback From the Field

Fannie Mae has been actively educating and soliciting feedback from its network of lenders, property owners and property evaluators. Since the PNA update was first published in October 2013, over 800 industry professionals have been trained on the new requirements. Says Romero, “Industry feedback received since the original publishing date led to an additional update published in January 2014.

“Input we have received from the property evaluator community has primarily centered around the qualifications for the property evaluator, which Fannie Mae addressed in the most recent PNA guidance update. Feedback from our lender partners has primarily been focused on the impact to replacement reserve schedules; however, initial feedback from multiple property evaluator firms indicates that the increase in replacement reserves is marginal and appropriate,” Romero says. 

Climbing the Learning Curve

While the changes are designed to improve the consistency and quality of PNAs, some firms could find it more challenging than others to get their processes in line with the new processes, forms and report structure. Form 4099’s standard report format will allow PNA reports to be reviewed more efficiently. The latest Instructions for the PNA Evaluator (Form 4099) can be found on 
Fannie Mae’s website.

Next Steps

All PNA Reports ordered on or after February 3, 2014 must adhere to the new PNA guidance. Fannie Mae will remain accessible to lenders and property evaluators to address feedback and questions resulting from the updated PNA guidance. The next version of the instructions is already underway based on Fannie’s outreach and additional feedback it has received from the lending community, property evaluators and owners, as well as other industry experts.The new requirements are minimum requirements by Fannie Mae. Lenders approved to deliver loans under Fannie’s Delegated Underwriting and Servicer (DUS) guidelines may also have additional requirements.

**
NOTE TO READERS:

EDR Insight would like to sincerely thank Fannie Mae’s Tammy Romero and EMG’s Greg Bailey, for their valuable contributions to this brief, as well as to our colleague, Tom Adams, for peer reviewing this brief prior to publication.

For more on EPA's ENERGY STAR® Score

Just this week, Fannie Mae issued a press release announcing its collaboration with the U.S. EPA in its development of an ENERGY STAR® score for multifamily properties. In Fall 2014, EPA will finalize a 1-100 ENERGY STAR ® score for multifamily housing properties in the ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager® tool. The 1-100 ENERGY STAR® score will be based on analyses of nationally representative survey data collected by Fannie Mae under a memorandum of understanding with EPA signed in 2011. As noted in the PR notice by Jeffery Hayward, Senior Vice President and Head of the Multifamily Mortgage Business, Fannie Mae. “The ENERGY STAR score will help the industry identify and implement energy-efficient methodologies that will improve property performance and conditions of multifamily properties.”

Click here to view the associated file

NameCategory
Building Energy Disclosure Laws Push Companies to Hire News
"Cluster Approach" to Cleanup May Launch Site ReuseNews
20-acre Reading brownfield to be cleaned, redevelopedArticles
2006 Hot Button Issues in Environmental Due DiligenceArticles
AAI: All A Matter of Perspective?Articles
Administrative Order Not Sufficient for Contribution ClaimArticles
All Appropriate Rule Out for Public CommentArticles
Another Court Strikes Down a Superfund Contribution CaseArticles
Arctic Undergoing Rapid Ice Melt That Could Speed Global Warming: StudyArticles
Asarco Deal Highlights Benefits of Liability Transfer StrategyArticles
Ash Pond Closures Update - October 2016News
ASTM Addresses Fundamental Conflict over Vapor IntrusionArticles
Bankruptcy Cases Dismissed After Court Finds 'Bad Faith' Articles
Bankruptcy Cases Dismissed After Court Finds 'Bad Faith'News
BFPP Affiliation LanguageNews
BNA Interview with Jeff TelegoArticles
BNA to Co-Sponsor ConferenceArticles
Brownfield Partners and EnviroFinance Group Join Forces to Boost Distressed Asset Redevelopment Across the United StatesNews
Brownfield Partners and EnviroFinance Group Join Forces to Boost Distressed Asset Redevelopment Across the United States News
Brownfields: Progress Made, But Further Actions NeededArticles
Buying Distressed Assets out of BankruptcyArticles
Cabot Corporation Agrees to Spend Over $84 Million to Control Harmful Air Pollution at Texas, Louisiana FacilitiesArticles
Case LawArticles
Case Law – Hydraulic FrackingArticles
CDC Acquires 425-Acre Distressed Steel Mill and Plans RedevelopmentNews
CDC Purchases AEP Power Plant, ELT Assumes Environmental LiabilitiesNews
CDC Reaches Major Milestone in the Reclamation of St. Louis QuarryArticles
CERCLA's BFPP Protections in QuestionArticles
Changes to Michigan’s Environmental Cleanup Program Coming Soon Articles
Changes to Michigan’s Environmental Cleanup Program Coming SoonNews
City & County of Denver and Adams County AgreeArticles
Claims Against Railroads Survive Arranger Liability RuleArticles
Commercial Development Company, Inc. Acquires 725-Acre Coal-Fired Power Plant, Prepares Site for Potential Development as Indiana’s Fourth PortNews
Commercial Development Company, Inc. Purchases 108-Acre Heavy-Industrial Waterfront Site in Antioch, CA for RedevelopmentNews
Commercial Development Company, Inc. Purchases 468-Acre Retired Coal-Fired Power Plant from AEP, Assumes Environmental Liabilities, Plans Demolition and RedevelopmentNews
Consultant Says Market Remains UncertainArticles
Contamination Not Required for Damage AwardArticles
CORPORATE SUSTAINABILITY IN THE UNITED STATES AND IMPROVING YOUR “CORPORATE PROFILEArticles
Court Affirms Judgment, Orders $3.1 Million PaymentArticles
Court Affirms Judgment, Orders $3.1 Million PaymentNews
Court Directed to Reconsider If Aviall May Recover Its CostsArticles
Court Orders Jackson to Issue Final Air Permit, Likely Bypassing EAB
Court Reverses Revocation of NFA Letter Articles
Court Rules on 3 Year Time Period for CERCLA Contribution ActionsArticles
Credit Crisis, Distressed Market Impacting Brownfield Sites, Redevelopment Articles
Death of Green Card Program Could Halt Brownfields ProjectsArticles
Deterring Citizen Suits: Remedies for Unsubstantiated ClaimsArticles
Developments EPA Lists Major Industries As Targets For First-Time Cleanup GuaranteesArticles
Dioxin Soil Cleanup StandardsArticles
DTE Energy Sells Coal Fired Power Plant to CDC/ELTArticles
DTE Energy sells Michigan power plant to Commercial Development Company, Inc.Articles
Due Diligence in the Era of Climate ChangeArticles
Due Diligence Standards-EPA All Appropriate InquiryArticles
EBA Media Release for June Meeting 20th Anniversary Articles
ELT Acquires 1,000,000 Square Foot GM Facility
ELT and Chemtura Close Transaction
ELT and Chrysler Close TransactionNews
Emerging Best Practice for Underwriting Energy Efficiency Loans - WebinarArticles
Emerging Best Practice for Underwriting Energy Efficiency Loans - WhitepaperArticles
Energy Disclosure Laws – A Nationwide Trend In TransparencyNews
EnviroFinance Group Joint Venture to Develope 3mW Solar Power Plant on Closed LandfillNews
Environmental Due Diligence Guide ReportArticles
Environmental Liability Transfer & Chemtura Close Transaction
Environmental Site Assessment Standards Revised by the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM)InternationalArticles
EPA Administrator Signs Proposed Rule Setting Standards for Site AssessmentsArticles
EPA Announces Cities with the Most Energy Star Buildings in the USArticles
EPA Announces Novel Superfund AgreementArticles
EPA Announces Schedule to Develop Natural Gas Wastewater Standards
EPA Announces U.S. Organizations Using the Most Green PowerArticles
EPA Announces Winner of Annual Energy Star National Building CompetitionArticles
EPA Disapproves Air Permitting Exemption Program in Texas Articles
EPA Embracing Green Cleanups, Standard ForthcomingArticles
EPA Embracing Superfund Policy to Expedite Site CleanupsArticles
EPA Faces Industry Pressure On Brownfields Rule On Eve Of ReleaseArticles
EPA Finalizes Greenhouse Gas Reporting Requirements for Petroleum and Natural Gas IndustryNews
EPA Issues Ready-for-Reuse GuidanceArticles
EPA Issues Rule to Reduce Water Pollution from Construction Sites News
EPA Issues Updated, Achievable Air Pollution Standards for Oil and Natural GasNews
EPA Lists Major Industries as Targets for First-Time Cleanup GuaranteesArticles
EPA Moves to Ease Groundwater Cleanup Policy Articles
EPA Plans Further Vapor Intrusion Revisions Amid New CriticismArticles
EPA Plans on Stepping Up Work on Vapor Intrusion Plan Articles
EPA Proposes Rule to Modernize Clean Water Act ReportingArticles
EPA Proposes to Keep Greenhouse Gas Permitting Requirements Focused on Largest Emitters News
EPA Proposes to Reduce Toxic Pollutants Discharged into Waterways by Power PlantsArticles
EPA Proposes to Replace and Reduce Harmful Greenhouse GasesArticles
EPA Pushes Back Final UST Regulation Articles
EPA RCRA Goals Require CreativityArticles
EPA Releases Final Risk Assessment on Trichloroethylene (TCE) Articles
EPA Releases New Policy Statement on Climate Change AdaptationArticles
EPA Report Shows Impact of Changing Climate on Americans’ Health and EnvironmentArticles
EPA Revises Consent Orders in Response to AviallArticles
EPA Rule Increases Protection from Lead-Paint Poisoning Articles
EPA Solicits Public Input on Using Vapor Intrusion Threats as Criteria for Superfund Sites News
EPA to Work with Ports to Improve Environmental Performance / Clean diesel grants and new ports initiative will advance sustainable technologiesArticles
EPA Will Review Cleanup Program PoliciesArticles
EPA's Integrated Cleanup Initiative Implementation Plan ProposedArticles
EPA, California OK Agreements To Waive City's LiabilityArticles
EPA, DOE to Study Potential for Renewable Energy Possibilities on West Haymarket Brownfield Site in Lincoln, Neb.News
EPA: Greenhouse Gases Threaten Public Health and the Environment Articles
ERRA Seminar: Environmental Insurance 101Articles
Fannie Mae Releases 1st PNA Guidance in Over 20 YearsArticles
Fed Reg Development - EPA Revisions to PCB Building Waste Rules Articles
Fed Reg Dev - EPA Relaxes Builders' Stormwater Permit News
Fed Reg Dev - EPA Seeking Comment On Re-classifying PCB-Contaminated Building Materials Slated For Disposal News
Fed Reg Dev Stormwater Violations at Concrete Ready-Mix Plants, Enforcement Nets More than $4 MillionArticles
Fed Reg Developments Articles
Fed Reg Drilling Final Rules on Drilling Emissions Articles
Federal Regulatory Developments – EPA on StormwaterNews
Federal Task Force Sends Recommendations to President on Fostering Clean Coal TechnologyArticles
Flawed Phase 1 CREC Definition Poses Challenges to Property Owners and LendersArticles
GE Discloses PCB-Related Expenses Under Shareholder PressureArticles
Georgia Power to close ash lagoons sooner, could cost $2 billionNews
Guardian Trust is Now OperationalArticles
Honeywell Representative to Speak at Deal Making & Redevelopments!Articles
Insurance against Extreme Events: Pairing Short-Term Incentives with Long-Term StrategiesArticles
Kelo Decision-Economic Development Can Be Public UseArticles
Kingdom Tower- Langan International and the World's Tallest Tower
Lack of Vapor Intrusion Guidance Muddies Issues; Effect on Redevelopment UncertainArticles
Law Provides No Exception for "Almost Innocent" OwnerArticles
Legal Title Not Necessary for Party to Bring Citizen LawsuitArticles
Liability Transfer of Asarco New Jersey Site from Bankruptcy to ELTArticles
LONG-AWAITED MCP CHANGES ARE AT OUR DOOR STEP Articles
Making Institutional Controls Work for California BrownfieldsArticles
Marysville looks to a riverfront renaissanceNews
Massachusetts Tops California as Most Energy-Efficient State, while Arkansas, D.C., Kentucky, and Wisconsin are Most ImprovedArticles
Merger & Acquisition Transaction Facilitated by EnvironmentalLiability Transfer, Inc.News
Military Pays for Real Estate Developer to Cleanup SiteArticles
More than 5,500 buildings to compete in EPA’s Fifth-Annual Energy Star Battle of the BuildingsArticles
N.Y. Residents Sue IBM Alleging ContaminationArticles
Natural Disasters Prompt Attention to Climate Change in Assessing RiskArticles
New Agency Task Force Developing Tracking DatabaseArticles
New ASTM Standard Aims to Provide More Accurate Measurement of Energy Use
New Bond Fund Helps Investors See Different Kind of GreenArticles
New Federal Court Case Signals Increased Litigation Over Vapor Intrusion ReopenersNews
New Law to Affect California Brownfields RedevelopmentArticles
News Release - EPA Updates Mercury and Air Toxics Standards for New Power Plants Articles
OCC Ratchets up Expectations – OCC Requirements for Environmental Due Diligence in Commercial Real Estate Lending Articles
On the Cutting Edge: An Insider's Perspective Favorable Market Trends Driving Contaminated Property TransactionsArticles
Opportunities Are Bright For Those Who Pave the WayArticles
Opposition to Aviall-Court Rules a PRP Can Seek ContributionArticles
P.E. Firms Find Way Around F.D.I.C. RulesArticles
Pacific Western Bank, San Diego, California, Assumes All of the Deposits of Los Padres Bank, Solvang, California Articles
Partner Leverages EDR’s New Technology Tools To Drive Even More Quality and Efficiency Articles
Purchaser of Assets Pursuant to Bankruptcy Sale Liable for Pre-Existing ContaminationArticles
RCRA Hazardous Waste Systems: Carbon Dioxide (CO2) Streams Being SequesteredNews
RCRA Suit May Include Property Adjacent to FacilityArticles
Real Property Protections for the Buyer
Recent Case Ruling Highlights Need for Informed Discussion, Agency Guidance
Reforming NCP Could Encourage Brownfields RedevelopmentArticles
Resource Damage Liability Precludes Contribution ClaimArticles
Responsible Parties May Be Able to Pursue Section 107 (a) ClaimsArticles
RTM Announces San Francisco, CA May 18-20, 2011 Conference
RTM Communications, Inc. and Bloomberg BNA Proudly Announce a Webinar "Closing Property Transactions Using Mitigation Banking Credits." Articles
RTM Conference Sponsor ELT Announced 80 New Jobs - Mid America Brick CompanyArticles
RTM Conference: The Bumpy Road to Brownfields RedevelopmentArticles
Sen. Clinton Introduces TCE (Trichloroethylene) LegislationArticles
Site Owner Must Allow Testing During Discovery
Solutions for Contaminated Real Estate Newsletter - August 2016News
Solutions for Contaminated Real Estate Newsletter - September 2016 Newsletter by Commercial Development Company, Inc. (CDC) and Environmental Liability Transfer, Inc. (ELT)News
SRS & LABBC Collaborate on Workshop Series to Train Contractors on PACE FinancingArticles
Strategy Shift on Global Warming Heralded by Collapse of Chicago Climate ExchangeArticles
Successor Firm Liable for Merger Firm's ViolationsArticles
Superfund and RCRA Reforms Effecting Contaminated Property Transactions for Brownfields RedevelopmentsArticles
Supreme Court Rejection of a Divisibility of Harm ArgumentArticles
Supreme Court Vacates Third Circuit Section 107(a) RulingArticles
Sustainability - Energy Improvement Corporation Announces $75 Million Agreement with Bank of America Merrill Lynch for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Program Articles
Sustainability - Retrofits Projected Yield $1Trillion in US Energy SavingsNews
Sustainability Energy Efficiency Market Projections 2013 to 2020Articles
Testimony of EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy Before Senate Environment and Public Works Committee on Proposed FY 2015 BudgetArticles
The Capital Markets Partnership (CMP) is launching the Sustainable Investment Initiative at the New York Stock Exchange. Articles
The End of Community Banking?Articles
Third of North American Birds Said to Face Extinction Due to Climate Change, Other Man-Made FactorsArticles
United States Reaches an Agreement with XTO Energy to Prevent Waste Spills from Natural Gas Exploration and Production Articles
United States Reaches Settlement with Safeway To Reduce Emissions of Ozone-Depleting Substances NationwideArticles
USDA, EPA Partnership Supports Water Quality Trading To Benefit Environment, EconomyArticles
Wells Fargo Supports Clean Technologies With New Commercial Banking Group Articles


Login
space